Eleazar ben Simon was a prominent Zealot leader during the First Jewish-Roman War (66–73 CE), a pivotal conflict between the Jewish population of Judaea and the Roman Empire. He is best known for his role in the defense of Jerusalem against Roman forces and his involvement in the internal Jewish civil strife that ultimately contributed to the city's fall in 70 CE. Historical accounts, primarily from the works of the Jewish historian Flavius Josephus, portray him as a fervent revolutionary committed to establishing an independent Jewish state, though his tactics and alliances often exacerbated divisions among the Jewish factions.
Little is definitively known about Eleazar ben Simon's early life, as historical records from the period are sparse and biased toward major events. He emerged as a significant figure around 66 CE, during the initial stages of the revolt against Roman rule. Eleazar ben Simon is believed to have been part of the radical Zealots faction, a group of Jewish militants who opposed Roman occupation and the collaborationist Jewish elite. His leadership qualities became evident in the early military successes against Roman legions.
In 66 CE, Eleazar ben Simon played a key role in the ambush and defeat of the Roman governor Cestius Gallus and his Legio XII Fulminata at the Battle of Beit Horon. This victory, which resulted in heavy Roman casualties and the capture of military standards and artillery, galvanized the Jewish revolt and boosted Eleazar ben Simon's reputation as a capable commander. The event marked a turning point, inspiring widespread rebellion across Judaea.
By late 66 CE, Eleazar ben Simon and his Zealots had gained control over parts of Jerusalem, including the Second Temple, which they seized in a bloody coup in 67 CE. This action expelled the moderate aristocratic priesthood led by Ananus ben Ananus, whom they viewed as too conciliatory toward Rome. Eleazar ben Simon's forces massacred the guards and asserted dominance over the Temple Mount, using it as a base for their operations.
Throughout the war, Eleazar ben Simon fought against advancing Roman armies under generals Vespasian and his son Titus Flavius. His strategy emphasized guerrilla warfare and fortified defenses, but internal rivalries undermined these efforts. He clashed with other Jewish leaders, notably John of Gischala and Simon bar Giora, leading to a civil war within Jerusalem in 69 CE. This infighting divided resources, demoralized fighters, and facilitated the Roman siege.
Eleazar ben Simon's radical policies, including the eradication of moderate elements and refusal of any negotiated peace with Rome, isolated potential allies. Josephus, who had defected to the Roman side, depicts him in Bellum Judaicum (The Jewish War) as impulsive and tyrannical, prioritizing personal ambition over unity. Despite this, some modern interpretations view him as a dedicated patriot whose zeal reflected broader aspirations for Jewish sovereignty amid Roman oppression.
Eleazar ben Simon perished during the fall of Jerusalem in 70 CE, likely in the final assaults on the Temple or the Upper City. The exact circumstances of his death are not recorded, but it coincided with the destruction of the Second Temple by Titus Flavius's forces on the 9th of Av. His leadership, while instrumental in prolonging the resistance, is often cited as a factor in the revolt's failure due to the factionalism it fostered.
In historical context, Eleazar ben Simon represents the militant strand of Jewish resistance during a era of intense Roman-Jewish tensions. He is distinct from Eleazar ben Ya'ir, the Sicarii leader at Masada, though both embodied the Zealot spirit. His story underscores the complexities of the First Jewish-Roman War, where ideological fervor clashed with strategic necessities.
Sources consulted include: